Taemin - 'Heaven, SITA, Guilty' at the KGMA and Minho - 'CALL BACK' at inkigayo - Reaction and Commentary
Added 2024-11-23 08:07:25 +0000 UTCTAEMIN delivered an absolute stand-out performance that will no doubt enter the history books as one of greatest K-pop soloist performances.
Minho also again proved himself as an very capable vocalist and dancer with his latest single.
His performance also managed to make us even more excited to react and review his newly released album.
Our reaction and review to the album will be available next week.
Comments
Taemin is on another level π
Mocha Williams
2025-01-19 02:55:29 +0000 UTCI joined patreon just to watch this Taemin reaction and I am thankful:)
Nina
2024-12-24 01:55:57 +0000 UTCIf you are going to do more SHINee MVs soon I'll give you a head's up, if you get to the WHY so serious MV you'll notice that Jonghyun is mmissing, even though it came out in 2013, this is because Jonghyun was in a car accident and injured his nose, SM decided to go with the comeback as planned instead of postponing it also bit until he healed, ththe other members pre-recorded the song as 4 (with Taemin covering most of Jonghyun's lines) and filmed the MV without him, they also promoted as 4. The album version has all 5 and there are concert versions with all 5 as well (notably the one from SWC5).
Ofra Cohen
2024-11-24 09:01:29 +0000 UTCyou guys saying that minho could be an actor made me stop to say: he is! he is part of 6 movies, almost 25 tv projects - he is the lead character in one netflix show -, he also made musicals and all
Beatriz Nalon
2024-11-24 00:52:50 +0000 UTCYESSSSSS. loved the reaction! AND YES HEAVEN IS >THAT< SONG. i dare to say the best bridge in kpop
Beatriz Nalon
2024-11-24 00:36:58 +0000 UTCKGMA Full performance fancam: https://youtu.be/CHySW6RBk40?si=2Z3IkV2OJcqYm_hl
Golonval3
2024-11-24 00:31:22 +0000 UTCSadly for this performance the official cameras were so disappointing. But there are very good fancams were you can appreciate the entire choreography. Iβll leave some links in the comments below :)
Golonval3
2024-11-24 00:27:09 +0000 UTCTrue! That is my favorite from Jonghyun. Love the funky and soulful notes from Jonghyun. Just mentioned Onew and Key whose comebacks were as recent. Ugh I miss Jonghyun as a long time Shawol I imagine where Jonghyun voice comes in newer SHINee songs.
S Kapdi
2024-11-23 17:50:40 +0000 UTCLet's not forget Jonghyun! His discography is true ART. Particularly 'She Is' has got to be one of my favorite albums of all time.
Lawol
2024-11-23 17:07:49 +0000 UTCmy favorite Keyβs album is Bad Love albumπsuch a masterpiece!
hyun tanchoi
2024-11-23 16:35:39 +0000 UTCyes for Media Bible!!!
hyun tanchoi
2024-11-23 16:34:48 +0000 UTCHe really brought out his best, think he said that since he knew the younger groups would bring their best he wanted to as well. Guilty is actually the title track of the album before Eternal, it's also called Guilty lol. It has an mv and everything too! https://youtu.be/pasRphQvEUE?si=o2AULfX4CZ0z-_ap Excited for the minho album reaction woo! He also actualy did some performances of his bsodes on msuic shows too. This one is cool cause it's live vocals and the dance is nice. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNMd8X0LzTA
A.R.R
2024-11-23 15:56:56 +0000 UTCYes! Key is my fave. His albums are cohesive and fun. Onew's work is phenomenal and their voices are so pretty.
S Kapdi
2024-11-23 14:23:07 +0000 UTCLoved the reaction just hoping you guys dig into Key and Onew that paints the complete picture as how strong they are as individuals as they are as a whole. Key and Onew have some of my favorite albums. I think you would be surprised by their discography.
S Kapdi
2024-11-23 14:22:14 +0000 UTCI hope you react to guilty music video on YouTube now that youβve heard the song! and canβt wait for the minho album reaction :)
S
2024-11-23 14:12:13 +0000 UTCThanks for enjoying Taemin's performance and I recommend this video!!!!!!!!!!!!! https://youtu.be/PhtvsSo_Ba8?si=uSQajDAn4r1UFB-6 People call it the Media Bibleππ This is one of his concert videos HOLY WATER (Japanese song) + HEAVEN +Shadow +Guess Who + Sexuality itβs not that long cuz itβs not the full song HEAVEN is really, really famous for this concert video !!! It's a different version of the performance from the kgma, but the original version is this and it's amazing AND thank you for always reacting to SHINee π«Άπ» i really like your video p.s. He performs this level of performance for two hours at a concert and even sings it upside down π΅βπ«π΅βπ«
min
2024-11-23 13:29:36 +0000 UTCGlad that you enjoy their solo perfomances. Taemin has so many good songs. You may enjoy "Rise" as well For minho, I really recommend you to check Came and Left Me live perfomance: https://youtu.be/F4uPs4CBMMA?si=4gNwxFCD_F_7tXKd The song highlights his voice and dance so well. In my opinion it's even better than call back π€£ A little fun fact, regardless that the members are from SM. They often mentioned on how they actually help and motivate each other to improve their skills. Usually, onew and jong help others practice in singing, taem and key in dancing, key and minho in rapping. The thing is each of them is REALLY good at their speciality. Thats why everyone is good at everything now. They learn from the best. Anyway, actually its onew and taemin who left SM for their solo activities, while minho and key continue their solo with SM. Cant wait for another SHINee's group/solo reaction from you next week :D
Aquilaa
2024-11-23 12:52:09 +0000 UTCPlease don't forget to check out the music videos for Onew - beat drum and Key - Pleasure Shop, their newest EP title tracks both released in September! All members have been busy with their solos this year. Hoping for a group comeback next year. And yes, you still have plenty of SHINee, as well as their older solo MV's remaining for potential marathons haha.
Lawol
2024-11-23 11:19:35 +0000 UTCSpeaking of Minho, I guess you forgot but there's a pretty extensive part in the guide dedicated to his acting career and accolades. He's one of the best known idol actors. So much so that he for the most part focused more on acting than music, which is mostly why he only debuted solo few years ago - he didn't have as much passion for pursuing solo career as other members at first, he recently said that. But once he released his first he got the sense of what it's like to make and promote music on your own and with the immense support of Shawols he got more ambitious for this project. Now he has a bigger drive to prove something as a solo artist and it's amazing to see how much fun he's genuinely having on stage! Minho has been improving tremendously both vocally and dance-wise and I think he's at his all time best currently. He stepped up a lot with his solo debut and also when SHINee promoted as 3 for a whole year with HARD. Taemin and Key were always the best dancers/performers in SHINee but Minho did not lose any bit, in fact he even stole the show in some of the performances, for instance, the first time they performed Body Rhythm last year everyone was talking about Minho (he's really feeling himself in the sensual sexy songs, and ofc his abs help :D). And yes, he's been taking some ballet lessons to strenghten his coordination and better execute the choreographies. You should also check out performances of the b-sides 'Came And Left Me' and 'Something About U' both of the choreos are more difficult than Call Back especially the latter one and he absolutely killed them! I'm excited to see your reaction to Call Back album next week, it's one of my favorite releases of the whole year.
Lawol
2024-11-23 10:54:37 +0000 UTCThe lyrics for Heaven were written by Taemin, so I'm happy you talked about how good they are. It's a b-side from his 2020 two part full album Never Gonna Dance Again (it's in Act 2), it's still my favorite Taemin album (both parts..). Guilty was a title track, and it went VIRAL, EVERYONE covered it, it even reached the anima fandom. Seeing as I've uploaded the Taemin performance, I don't think you'll have a problem with it. By the way, the crowd was VERY muted in the Taemin performance, if you watch the fancams, they are VERY loud. There's a fancam showing Ricky from ZB1 reaction to the Guilty fan chants, he was SHOCKED. Taemin always leaves the other idols shocked and in awe when he performs in front of them, there are MANY fancams of it. I remember the reactions to his MAMA performance of DOOR, that was also an insane one... Minho IS an actor, he started acting in 2010, the second to do it in SHINee (all of them accept for Jonghyun have acted in a show or movie), Taemin was actually the first but many people aren't aware of that... Both Taemin and Onew left SM, at about the same time.
Ofra Cohen
2024-11-23 10:24:01 +0000 UTCDon't get me wrong this Taemin stage was awesome but tbh it's a regular day in office for him :D he always delivers the highest class performances if you watch his concerts there's even more impressive ones imho. Guilty was his last release with SM from last year which is sort of the new Move for him and went viral for the iconic dance. It's the song that was nominated in different award shows like MAMA this year. Heaven is actually a b-side! I know, crazy. It would totally do as one of the best title tracks for any other artist but for Taemin it's just a regular b-side track lol. It's one of my personal favorites especially among his relatively newer songs (it's from his last full album under SM 'Never Gonna Dance Again' relased in 2020 and it's full of amazing songs). Taemin has won 3 awards at the KGMA's for: Best Artist, Best Solo Artist, Best Popularity Artist. That doesn't sound like someone who's underrated :D Like I get you probably mean views, streams, subs and all of that but it's not the main or the most important metric. He's definitely one of the biggest and most established solo artists right now and has been for many years already, rightfully so. And the reactions from other idols you see to his and SHINee performances is one of the best proofs of that, they are always either super hyped or just in awe shocked. Taemin was the host of reality competition survival show from Mnet ''Road to Kingdom: Ace of Ace'' this year that just recently ended; he's known to be the ace of K-pop.
Lawol
2024-11-23 10:05:50 +0000 UTCthank you so much for your reaction to Taemin!! In fact, most of Taeminβs performance especially, concert performances have that level of perfection and execution. i am thrilled to see more reaction videos from you guys to Taeminβs concert performances. oh btw Tokyo waterbomb performance as well another levelβ¦
hyun tanchoi
2024-11-23 09:57:19 +0000 UTCTaemin is the BEST Artist in Kpop and in my opinion one of the best performers globally. And you are right; he is so underrated. Actually I am one of those who came to kpop because of Taemin. I was watching a Japanese TV show in which Taemin had a main role and I kind of found him interesting and googled him and saw one of his live performances of MOVE and me .. WHO IS THIS, why the world does not knowing about him. After that I checked everything in kpop just to find out that I had already discovered THE BEST.. yes there are other good performers, vocalists and dancers BUT he is the whole package, the best performer, the most avant-garde and creative. His dedication and passion to his work is extraordinary. He keeps amazing me. Shinee was/is an extraordinary group. They were way ahead of their time. Those 5 coming together was the best thing what happened in kpop. They brought so much creativity and new things into kpop. They didnβt want just to be famous and make money but leaving a foot print with their musicality. Taemin has been mentored a lot by Jonghyun (Taamin is his legacy to us) and Onew and worked so hard to reach the level he has.. look at him, this impressive live performance. You should watch his concerts . You wonβt regret it. With regard Minho. We talk how underrated Taemin is but Minho is even more. He has such a soothing voice and he also wrote many songs for Shinee.. And please let me say: you both are so great. I like watching you reactions so much. Thank you for reacting and appreciating Taemin and Shinee.. And thank you for Ofra..for representing Taemin in such a good way!!!
Lola Montez
2024-11-23 09:55:51 +0000 UTCCheck Guilty! But to experience the hole storytelling you need to check the trailers in order first, trailers + MV are supposed to complement everything
Golonval3
2024-11-23 09:51:22 +0000 UTCMinho is a very sucessful actor. He just had a show on Netflix called Romance in the House.
Patricia
2024-11-23 09:19:26 +0000 UTCGuilty actually came out last year on his first mini album after getting out of the military. Taemin used to train vocally so hard that he would get nosebleeds.
Patricia
2024-11-23 09:18:10 +0000 UTCTAEMIN you beast on stage. But will always be the maknae to the members and the Fans. There is no one like Shinee. 2 members had to leave SM for Minho to get a Full length Album. Onew is also no longer with SM, both Taemin and Onew left SM on the same day or we got to know on the same day. You should check Onew new Album Flow he wrote the lyrics and produced the entire Album. The amount of pride shawols have or the superiority complex we have because we Stan Onew(Lee Jinki), Kim Jonghyun,Key (Kim Kibum), Choi Minho and Lee Taemin. There is no one like them,and there Solo's are so different from each other that it's so refreshing . 2024 busy year for shawol because we had back to back solo comeback from all the 4 members. The members always support each other's solo's and they never try to over shadow other and are always proud of each other's achievement β€οΈ
PB
2024-11-23 09:07:52 +0000 UTCplease react ateez kgma too They won their first daesung
cemre^^
2024-11-23 08:30:42 +0000 UTC
