Butt Bros (Pt 2)

Read Pt 1 here 

Later that night, Aaron came into my room with his laptop and a shy look on his face.

“Don’t judge me or anything...” he said, moving his laptop toward me. “I just saw this online and, I dunno, it seemed like it could be fun.” His browser was open to a page of a sex store, specifically a listing for a thick, green, double-ended dildo.

“Oh damn,” I said, thinking of what to say. The truth was I’d had the same thought – that it might be hot for us to be connected in that way when we stuffed our holes. Like killing two birds with one stone.

“What do you think?” Aaron said.

“I think I’ll go halves with you on that,” I said, and Aaron laughed.

So we ordered it, and then we were all horned up from the idea of it so we decided to jack off. Aaron grabbed his dildo. He followed my lead this time and we sat on them at the same time.

“I do like it like this,” he said, bouncing on his dildo and tweaking the nipples on his fit pecs.

“It’s good, right?” I said, bouncing away. “Sort of a different sensation than lying back and taking it.” We came like that, all over my bedroom floor, and Aaron was kind enough to clean it up.

The double-dong arrived in the mail the next day. It felt a little awkward at first, checking it out and knowing we were going to be stuffing it in our holes at the same time. It was a bit bigger than our other toys, I noted.

“I like a challenge, though,” I said.

“I think I’m gonna shave first,” Aaron said. “Seems like I can take one easier when I’m shaved clean.” I knew that Aaron kept his body hair trimmed. I’m a bit hairier than him and I hadn’t shaved my pubes since high school. I’d never shaved my asshole at all. But all the sudden I was intrigued. “I can help you if you want,” Aaron said.

So that’s how we found ourselves in the bathroom ready to shave ourselves. I worked on clearing my pubes first. And then, one after the other, we lathered up our asses and took turns bending over and bracing ourselves against the wall, while the other glided the razor over our cheeks and holes, clearing the hair away bit by bit. It was the closest I’d ever gotten to his ass, and I have to say, it was a pretty sweet butt – firm and round, with a nice pink hole. It took a while to do both of us but it was so cool to feel it afterward – just total smoothness. It got us super horny, too – we were popping boners the entire time.

“Ready to do this, bro?” Aaron said, reaching back to feel his shaved hole. I think he even sank a finger inside. 

“Fuck yeah I am,” I said, and our shaved-bare boners led the way as we headed to Aaron’s room (he had the bigger bed). He had the double-dong laying there as well as an industrial-sized pump bottle of lube that he’d ordered with it. So we lubed up our holes and Aaron got both ends of the dildo nice and slick. We couldn’t sit on it at the same time, obviously, so we got on our backs, legs up, ass to ass, and positioned each end of the dildo at our holes. Aaron sank his end in first.

“Fuck it’s thick,” he said. I had the knobby head of my end up against my hole and I bore down. The shock of it, when it first popped inside, took my breath away. But I looked over and there was four inches of it completely sunk in Aaron’s hairless hole. That was enough motivation for me to take more, and pretty soon the spasms stopped and it was feeling pretty goddamn good. We had to scoot a little closer to each other to take more, but we managed to get about seven inches apiece stuffed inside ourselves.

“Fuck this is crazy,” Aaron said. “Getting our asses fucked at the same time.”

“Gimme more,” I said, cause I was honestly about as turned on as I’ve ever been. Aaron held the middle steady as I sank down on it more. Then he started moving the middle, so that we were getting fucked at the same time. We took turns pumping it and got into a good rhythm, jacking as we pumped. It really did seem like my shaved hole made it easier to take – it just slid in and out of me like butter.

“Fuck yeah,” Aaron said as I worked it – into him, out of me; into me, out of him. “Keep pumping it like that. Fuck that’s gonna make me cream.” His breath was getting fast so I let myself get close too. As we got to the edge, he reached for the dildo almost reflexively, his hand closing around mine – our asses were so hungry we were both gunning for control of the dildo. We pumped it in tandem until Aaron started to shoot. The first jet went so high I couldn’t believe it and kinda laughed, but then I was cumming too and shooting mine up into the air. Our cum was landing all over our bodies and at first I was thinking about avoiding getting my load on him and vice versa, but then I just didn’t care.

“Holy fuck, bro,” Aaron said.

“Damn straight,” I said.

“I don’t know if this is your cum or mine all over me,” he said.

“Same,” I said. “Kinda don’t care.”

“Exactly!” Aaron said, and we slid it out of ourselves. Then he slapped palms with me and we laughed as we caught our breath. “Best orgasm ever!”

That double-dong practically became our third roommate. We kept it in Aaron’s room, usually. Sometimes I would use it alone, because it really did stretch me out good. Or maybe it was the fact that it was both of ours, shared, and there was something hot about that.

One day Aaron came home to find me on my back in his bed, with one end of our shared toy stuffed up inside myself.

“Oh hell yeah, bro, let me go grab a shower real quick,” he said, and not ten minutes later he was butt-ass naked, walking into his room with his shaved hard-on bobbing. He kicked back and took his place on the other end, and we rode that toy till we both creamed.

Eventually we got into riding it doggy-style: both of us on our hands and knees, the joined by the double-dong. It was hot cause you could just push your ass back to sort of take it and give it at the same time. I couldn’t help but think of how hot we must look like that – two hard-bodied jocks, smooth and shaved, our muscled butts bent over and stuffed full of silicone. We would usually get on our backs when it was time to cum, letting it fly all over ourselves. We got to where we liked spraying cum on each other and would make a point of trying.

The thing is, we never talked about what it all meant. If it did mean anything. Aaron and I, we’d both had girlfriends from time to time. I had moments where I thought the obvious stuff: We’re shaving each other’s assholes and cumming together while getting our holes stuffed on an almost daily basis. It’s kinda, well...you know. But it wasn’t like I was in love with Aaron. He was just my good bro. Who was kinda freaky, like me.

Now Aaron had this other bro named Louis, who worked with him. They would go to the gym together and stuff, too. I liked Louis, and all three of us would chill sometimes. He was a good-looking guy, real swole, and had a good personality. But we weren’t close like he was with Aaron.

One weekend I left town to visit my sister, except she wound up having an emergency at work so I came back early and didn’t think to text Aaron. Once again, I walked in on him unexpectedly. I mean, I wasn’t surprised to hear what sounded like him stuffing his hole - both of us stuffed our holes multiple times a day. But as I got closer to his room it sounded more like sex, and I got the shock of my life when I passed his door and saw him there, bent over in his bed, with Louis behind him, naked and railing Aaron’s ass with his huge cock. Aaron was loving it, too – all but begging for it – and Louis had this grin on his face like he was fucking the greatest piece of all time.

Thankfully neither of them heard me, and I was able to slip into my bedroom where I caught my breath. Then I sat on my bed and tried to figure out what the fuck I was gonna say once Aaron realized I was home.

To Be Continued...