Butt Bros

I was not prepared to find my bro and roomie Aaron on all fours stuffing his asshole with a dildo that day when I got home from work. To be fair, he wasn’t expecting me to be home that early – which is probably why he’d left his bedroom door open.

“Fuck! Jeremy!” he said, pulling the dildo out of himself and scrambling.

“Sorry bro,” I said, weakly, then went to my room and shut the door, mind reeling. I had no idea Aaron like to have his hole stuffed – I mean, we pick up chicks on the regular and we’ve even railed one together a few times. But the crazy thing was, I’d been working my hole in secret since I was a teenager – first with my fingers, then with a dildo I stole from my sister. Over the years I’d bought a few more toys – a plug, a bigger dong. Fucking myself up the ass got me off big time. Apparently Aaron and I had that in common.

But that didn’t help the awkwardness of the situation. Aaron knocked on my door a couple minutes later, wanting to talk. He was still kinda red-faced and I wondered if he’d gotten off after I caught him or if his balls were still loaded.

“Sorry again, man,” I said.

“It’s cool, I just...I got curious, and remember that girl Priyanka? I was fucking her back in the summer? She gave me that dildo, like as a joke...”

“Bro, it’s okay...you don’t have to explain...I...” I faltered, then made a decision. “Look,” I said, walking to my dresser and pulling out my favorite dildo: a thick black one, veined and ridged just like a cock, which was been up my tight jock ass too many times to count.

“Whoa, bro – you too?” Aaron said.

“Dude, I’ve been stuffing my hole since I was a teenager,” I said. “Gets me off big time.”

“That’s fucking crazy,” Aaron said, gazing at the big dildo. “Alright – truth is I’ve been fucking myself with that dildo almost every night since she gave it to me. She even fucked me with it once. I mean I usually shut my door but I thought you’d be home later.”

“Bro,” I said, shaking my head. “It’s no sweat. Now we don’t have to be all secretive about it, you know?” Aaron looked into my dresser at the trove of toys.

“Whoa, you’ve got a fuckin arsenal in here,” he said, picking up the fat butt plug I liked the most. “What’s this one feel like?”

“Fuckin good,” I said, and realized I was chubbing up. “It sinks in you and stretches you out like crazy. But you can even walk around with it in and it kinda turns you on the whole time.”

“Have you ever done that?”

“One time I wore it to work,” I said.

“Dude that’s sick!” Aaron said.

“Borrow it if you want,” I said, surprising myself. But Aaron is my bro, we’ve done everything together – including a couple stoned jack-off sessions. I didn’t care if something that had gone up my ass went up his, or vice versa – it’s made of silicone and I can wash the fucking thing.

“You serious?” Aaron said. “Sweet! I’m gonna go try it right now.”

“Yeah I kinda figured I blew your chances at getting off. Sorry about that.”

“Naw, bro, it’s cool, and now I got a new toy to try out.”

“You gotta let me know how it goes,” I said.

“Totes,” Aaron said, and headed down the hall to his room where he shut the door. I thought about him in there, stuffing his butt with my plug, and was surprised to find that the idea of us sharing it turned me on.

Aaron brought it back to me the next day. “Don’t worry, man, I cleaned it real good. Fuck that felt amazing! I came as soon as I got it stuffed in me all the way.”

“Always does it for me, too,” I said, putting it back in my drawer. “You’ll have to let me try yours sometime.”

“Yeah? You want it right now?” Aaron said.

“Honestly? I’m super fucking horny. So yeah,” I said. And that was how my bro and I shared our dildos for the first time. I closed my door, too, but I knew he was out there, so I moaned maybe extra loud. But there was something hot about using what had been inside him. I even sniffed it a little, first.

That Sunday we were just sitting around cause it was snowing outside and everything was closed, anyway. We were watching this dating show and I guess getting kinda horny cause we were both tweaking our dicks under our shorts.

“I might need to head to my room and stuff my butt,” Aaron said.

“Would it be weird if we did it together?” I said after a minute.

“Dude, I’ve been thinking the same thing,” Aaron said. Which was how we wound up butt-ass naked in our living room, greasing up our dildos with coconut oil and getting ready to stuff our assholes at the same time.

“I like to sit on it first,” I said, holding my black dong on the couch and perching myself on top of it. “Offsets that initial pain.”

“I dunno, bro, I kinda like that intense feeling when it first goes in,” Aaron said. He was kicked back on the couch with his legs up, running his dong over his pink hole. We sank them in ourselves at the same time, looking at each other while we did it. It was hot to see the way his face screwed up in pain – I guess I probably looked the same – and the way his hole stretched out around. Once we’d gotten them in we smiled at each other.

“There’s no feeling like this, bro,” I said, stroking my cock as I bounced up and down on that dong. “So intense.”

“I know, bro,” Aaron said, pumping his ass full of dildo. “I never knew what I was missing until I started doing this. I seriously have to hold off cause I’ll cum too quick.” His cock was pulsing against his stomach, hard as hell.

We didn’t last long that first time. I wound up kicking back on the couch next to him, half-focused on the porn we had playing on the TV and also on Aaron’s stuffed-full hole. We came at the same time – Aaron gave me a warning and I timed it with him. Then we washed our dildos together, laughing with the relief of, yeah, a good orgasm, but also coming clean about something you’re ashamed of. It was a bonding thing, for sure.

The next day I came home from work to find Aaron just like I had a week ago: door open, ass-up, dildo working overtime into his tight ass. But this time he just smiled when he saw me.

“Been horned up all day, dude. Sorry I didn’t shut my door,” he said.

“Dude it’s cool,” I said as I shucked off my shoes. “I’m fucking horny too – mind if I join you?”

“Not at all, man,” he said. I kinda figured he’d left his door open on purpose. Truth was it was fun getting off together. I got naked – hard cock bobbing around – and was about to go grab my dong from my room when Aaron pulled his dildo out of himself and offered it to me.

“We can take turns if you want,” he said.

“Cool with me bro,” I said. The dildo was warm and slicked up from being in his ass. I laid back next to him on the bed, legs in the air, and slid the dildo that had just been inside him, inside of me. “Oh fuck that feels good,” I said. It was a total thrill using the same dildo as him. When I’d got myself close I handed it back to him and watched as he fucked himself. We traded back and forth for a while until he shot a huge load all over himself. Then he handed the dildo back to me and I did the same thing, pumping my ass all the while.

Read Pt 2 here